top of page
wine and entrees from Mangia Mangia, a Key West pasta cafe

Our Menu

EACH DISH AT OUR PASTA CAFE IS MADE FRESH IN-HOUSE WITH CARE—
AND A LITTLE KEY WEST SOUL.
green pattern updated.png

House-Made Pasta & Sauces,
Key West Style

There’s something special about fresh-made pasta — the texture, the flavor, the way it holds a rich, house-made sauce. It’s a taste of tradition you might not expect in Key West, but once you find it, it’s unforgettable.
 

Most of our pastas are crafted daily with semolina flour and eggs, while select varieties are made egg-free or gluten-free. We also offer Zucchini Ribbon-Zoodles for a lighter, veggie-forward option.
 

Because our pasta is made fresh in small batches, availability may vary — but our team is always happy to suggest a delicious alternative.

fresh pasta from Mangia Mangia, a Key West pasta cafe
Pouring Semolina flour for fresh made pasta cafe in Key West
pasta stencil drawing showcasing the variety of fresh pasta at Mangia Mangia

Pasta Cafe:Your Way

Our selection includes:
Fettuccine, Linguini, Spaghetti, Fusilli, Rigatoni, Mostaccioli, Pappardelle, Ravioli, and Zucchini Ribbon-Zoodles. We also make gluten & egg free options


Pair your pasta with one of our house-made sauces, infused with fresh herbs and prepared from scratch:

  • Marinara

  • Meat Sauce

  • Alfredo

  • Pesto with pine nuts and walnuts

  • Creamy Marinara

  • Creamy Pesto​

Don't Eat Pasta? Eat a Fresh House Salad; OR have your entree placed on a bed of spinach

shrimp scampi and pasta at Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe

Island Comfort, Family Style

Every plate is made to order — fresh, flavorful, and crafted with care.

Beyond pasta, our menu features hearty soups, vibrant appetizers, local seafood, grilled entrees, and a touch of tropical flair. Pair your meal with a selection from our curated wine list, and don’t miss our famous Key lime pie! Can you guess the secret ingredient?

Our Family Fave's

Fusseli Bowl with Alfredo   

Caprese Salad

Chicken Piccatta

Carbonara with Fresh Sea Scallops

green pasta pattern.png
Our Menu


SOUP, SALAD, AND APPETIZERS




CONCH CHOWDER

A Key West Classic. Tomato-based Manhattan-style Chowder garnished with Parsley.

$0



HOUSE SALAD

Fresh Romaine & Boston Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Onions, Arugula tossed with our special Vinaigrette.

$0



ADD any 3 of the following ingredients for an extra

Roasted Red Peppers, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Artichoke Hearts, Feta Cheese, Gorgonzola, Garbanzo Beans or Fresh Organic Basil.

$3.00



CAPRESE

Sliced Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, EVOO & Balsamic Vinegar.

$0



CARPACCIO di BUE*

Paper-Thin Slices of Beef Loin, Sashimi-Style, dressed with Fresh Lemon Juice and EVOO, garnished with Capers, Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Arugula, topped with Fresh Ground Pepper & Sea Salt.

$0



GRATIN of GRILLED ASPARAGUS

Grill-Roasted Asparagus and Vine-Ripened Plum Tomatoes brushed with EVOO, Garlic and Herbs, topped with Gorgonzola then lightly browned.

$0



ESCARGOTS on GRILLED GARLIC CROUTON

Sautéed in Butter & EVOO with Garlic, Shallots, White Wine and Fresh Pesto, served over a Grilled Garlic Crouton.

$0



BRUSCHETTA

Chopped Fresh Homemade Mozzarella, Basil & Tomatoes marinated in EVOO with Garlic, Lemon and Onions. Served over Grilled Garlic Crouton.

$0



NEW ZEALAND MUSSELS

Green-Lipped Mussels infused with Garlic, Butter, Chopped Tomatoes, Basil, Red Pepper Flakes and White Wine.

$0



BROCCOLI RABE (RAPPINI)

Sautéed in EVOO, Garlic, Chopped Tomatoes, a dash of Red Pepper Flakes and Shaved Parmesan Cheese. One of our most-requested dishes.

$0




HOUSE SPECIALTIES

We use naturally-fed, non-hormone Chicken.




FETUCCINE e SAUTÉED CHICKEN

with EVOO & Garlic Pesto, Marinara, Alfredo, Creamy Marinara, or Pesto Sauces

$0



RAVIOLI al FORMAGGIO

Your choice of Sauce

$0



POLLO or MAHI PICCATTA

White Wine, Capers, Butter, Lemon Juice, Garlic, Shallots & Parsley with a side of Fresh Fusilli Pasta, topped with Creamy Alfredo Sauce. Swap Chicken for Mahi

$0



POLLO al QUATTRO FORMAGGIO

Thin Spaghetti, Diced Chicken Breast in a Rich Cream Sauce, with Parmesan, Romano, Fontanella and Gorgonzola Cheeses and topped with Walnuts.

$0



POLLO con FUNGHI e PISELLI

Diced Chicken Breast & Fresh Mushrooms sautéed in EVOO with Garlic, Shallots, Green Peas and served over Thin Spaghetti with a Marinara Sauce.

$0



POLLO PARMESANO

We dust our tender Chicken with Gluten-Free Flour and Pan-Sautée it, cover it with our Marinara Sauce, and top it with fresh Mozzarella Cheese. Served with a side of our Fussill Pasta and our Homemade Marinara.

$0



POLLO MARSALA

Our delicious non-hormone Chicken lightly coated with GLUTEN FREE Rice Flour, sautéed with Butter, Garlic, Shallots, Mushrooms in Marsala Wine Sauce. Served with a side of Fusilli Alfredo.

$0



ZUCCHINI RIBBONS - ZOODLES

Low carb/gluten-free Zoodles (Zucchini Ribbons) with Mushrooms and sautéed in EVOO, Garlic & Shallots, finished with a sprinkle of Romano Cheese & Lemon Wedge Add Shrimp

$0



SPAGHETTINI SCHMAPPELLINI

Our homemade Spaghetti tossed with Asparagus, Basil, Garlic and Tomatoes in a savory Vegetable Consommé. Finished with Toasted Pine Nuts & Shaved Parmesan Cheese.

$0



FUNGHI al POMODORI, SPINACI e CECI

Fresh Mushrooms sautéed in EVOO with Garlic, Shallots, Tomatoes, Garbanzos, Pesto & Fresh Spinach. Served over Pappardelle, topped with crumbled Feta Cheese.

$0



MOSTACIOLLI with BROCCOLI RABE RAPPINI

Wild Broccoli Rabe flash-sautéed in EVOO with Garlic, Red Pepper Flakes, Chopped Tomatoes, and Grilled Sausage with Pinenuts and topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese.

$0



SPAGHETTINI alla CARBONARA*

A rich sauce of Parmesan Cheese, flavorful Pancetta, Sautéed Garlic, Black Pepper, Peas and tossed with a Fresh Egg. Add Chicken or Shrimp (add-on)

$0




SEAFOOD SPECIALTIES




SEAFOOD in a SAUCE

with 3 Shrimp, Conch & Mahi-Mahi. Marinara or Alfredo

$0



SEAFOOD SCAMPI

Maine Lobster, Shrimp and Lump Blue Crab, White Wine, Garlic, Butter, Parsley and Clam Broth over Fresh Linguini Pasta.

$0



LOBSTER LINGUINE

Maine Lobster Claw & Knuckle in our Pink Sauce (Creamy Four Cheese Marinara Sauce).

$0



LINGUINE con VONGOLE

Fresh Little Neck Clams steamed in a bath of White Wine, Spanish Onions, Garlic, Parsley and a dash of Red Pepper Flakes. Finished with Butter & Lemon Zest.

$0



BOLLITO MISTO di MARE

Our tribute to the ocean’s bounty features Pappardelle Pasta, Fresh Scallop, Shrimp, Salmon, Mussel and Mahi-Mahi flash-sautéed in EVOO with Garlic, Shallots, Pesto, Thyme, White Wine and finished in an Herbaceous Clam Broth. Garnished with Chopped Tomatoes & Green Peas.

$0



NEW ZEALAND MUSSELS with SPAGHETTINI

Imported Green-Lipped Mussels in a Garlicky Marinara Sauce, Basil, Red Pepper Flakes, topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese. Also available with a Garlicky White Wine Sauce.

$0



FRESH SEA SCALLOPS

Large, tender Scallops sautéed in Butter & Garlic, tossed with Spinach Fettuccine and a Fresh Pesto & Cream Sauce.

$0

FRESH SEA SCALLOPS


SPINACH FETTUCCINE ALFREDO with JUMBO LUMP BACKFIN BLUE CRABMEAT

Our Spinach Fettuccini mixed with our delicious homemade Alfredo Sauce, topped with Jumbo Lump Blue Crab sautéed in Butter.

$0

SPINACH FETTUCCINE ALFREDO with JUMBO LUMP BACKFIN BLUE CRABMEAT


RIGATONI with JUMBO SHRIMP

Sautéed in EVOO with Prosciutto, Garlic, Black Olives, Shallots, Fresh Tomatoes and Red Pepper Flakes. Topped with a garnish of Arugula, and a dusting of of Romano Cheese.

$0

RIGATONI with JUMBO SHRIMP



BUILD YOUR OWN ENTREE

Pair pasta with one of our herb-infused sauces, add in a protein if you choose. All entrees served with Garlic Butter Rosemary Toast. Kids under 12 may ask for a smaller bowl, ½ portion size




Choose A Homemade Pasta (While Supplies Last)

Noodles made with Hearty Semolina Grain Fettucini-regular or spinach infused Linguini Spaghetti Fusilli Mostaciolli Pappardelle Ravioli with 3 cheese

$0



Homemade Sauces

Marinara Meatsauce Alfredo Creamy Marinara Pesto with Pine Nuts and Walnuts Creamy Pesto

$0



Add a Protein (Optional)

Shrimp Link Sausage Meatballs Chicken Pieces OR Choose one of our Suggested Favorites from the Grill

$0



Gluten and Egg Free Options"

Gluten & Egg Free Pasta Zucchini Ribbons Egg Free Fettucine Noodle

$0




FAVORITES FROM THE GRILL

Served with Fusilli, Marinara. Grill Entrées may be served with the House Salad for those not wishing Fresh Pasta.




GRILLED FRESH ATLANTIC SALMON

Brushed with EVOO, Lemon Juice, Garlic and Pepper.

$0



FRESH MAHI-MAHI

Brushed with EVOO, Lemon Juice, Garlic and Pepper.

$0



GRILLED BONELESS CHICKEN BREAST

Brushed with EVOO, Lemon Juice, Garlic and Pepper.

$0




SKIP THE PASTA & SAUCE

Skip the pasta & sauce and go for a big, fresh house salad with or without protein.





IMPORTANT INFO

- Kindly ask for separate checks when ordering. - $20 corkage fee. - 18% gratuity may be added to your check at our discretion. - We accept cash, MasterCard, American Express, VISA, and Discover. *Eating undercooked or raw food can increase your chances for food-borne illnesses



Contact Us

305-294-2469

Address

900 Southard Street
Key West, FL 33040

Opening Hours

5:30pm - 10pm Daily

Please note we do not take any reservations or online orders via email.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Yelp!
  • TripAdvisor
Pasta to the People - Mangia Mangia logo

©2025 by Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe. 

bottom of page