top of page
Our Story
FROM OUR FAMILY TO YOURS, SINCE 1989
Fresh, Handmade Pasta
Made Daily, Just for You
Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe is a true Key West gem. Nestled on a tree-lined street in the heart of Old Town, this family-owned restaurant has been a beloved spot since 1989. Here, you’ll find homemade pastas, bold sauces, and the freshest local seafood - served with a tropical twist on classic Italian flavors. It’s the kind of place that feels like a locals’ favorite and a hidden treasure just waiting to be discovered.
Known for crafting fresh pasta daily, Mangia Mangia offers hearty semolina wheat pastas, along with gluten-free and egg-free options to ensure every guest can enjoy a plate of exceptional pasta. Each dish is paired with our signature house-made sauces, creating a truly memorable dining experience. Our menu celebrates authentic Italian cuisine with a Key West twist, and no visit is complete without a slice of our famous Key lime pie.
"Experience the remarkable secret of Key West: Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe is a must-visit!"
_edited.jpg)
What Makes our
Key West Restaurant Special
What really makes Mangia Mangia special is our people. Many of our team members have been with us for nearly 20 years, ensuring that every guest receives warm, familiar, and exceptional service. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, catching up with old friends, or simply enjoying a great meal, you’ll always be welcomed like family. Our cozy dining room and charming outdoor garden, lit by twinkling lights, create the perfect atmosphere for any occasion.
We’re proud to support our community, local schools, and artists. We’ve even created a dedicated gallery space to showcase their work. At the heart of it all is owner and manager Heather "Sunny" Weather, who has been welcoming guests with a smile for years. Thanks to her leadership, her husband Michael's attention to detail, and the incredible team, Mangia Mangia remains a cherished part
of Key West.
Over the years, our commitment to quality and hospitality has earned us numerous accolades, including Best Keys Eats, Wine Spectator, and our local Key West Bubba Awards, to name a few.
But the true reward? Knowing that we’ve become a cherished part of the community.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Mangia Mangia is a place where you’ll always feel at home.
A Holiday Tradition Like No Other
For the past 15 years, we've proudly kept a unique tradition alive—bringing snow to our balcony every Christmas season, making us the only place in KW where it truly snows during the holidays! It's become a magical sight for the community and a highlight of the season. And yes, that mischievous Grinch you see each year? That’s actually my son in costume, helping spread a little holiday cheer (and mischief)!
bottom of page